Sunday, January 25, 2009

Fincher's Digital Button

I saw "The Curious Caste of Benjamin Button" on Friday,  and now am reading F. Scott Fitzgerald's short-story of the same name; reading it more out of curiousity than anything else, since the connection between the movie and the fiction is tenuous.  As the Times'  A.O Scott noted in his review of the Fincher film, a more profound and obvious  influence on the movie is the preceeding work of directors like Steven Spielberg, Peter Jackson, and Robert Zemeckis - more specifically, the films where they create characters - or even entire worlds - out of computer-generated digital imagery.  I'm fine with the trend toward digital effects in the cinema - it's after one more technical advance at the disposal of our imaginitive resources - but it's wrong to think that the "better" digital technology becomes the more realistic it necessarily is.  While not thinking that Fincher's "Button" is a complete failure, I nonetheless found that there was something false and unbelieveable in Bratt Pitt's aging-in-reverse;  it seems to me that the film's lack of believability is directly related to its reliance on digital trickery.

Friday, January 23, 2009

I find myself both impressed and bemused by how easily Europeans integrate "the life of mind" with more popular and casual aspects of their daily cultural fare. Case in point: the German e-zine, Sign and Sight, which I recently discovered browsing for information about current students of Heidegger (yeah, I know that sounds pompous but it's the sort of thing I actually do). In the process I came across Habermas's touching acknowledgment of Richard Rorty's death, which includes his passing along Rorty's blithe nod at the fact he was going to die of the same cancer which killed Derrida, a disease his daughter remarked must have been induced by "reading too much Heidegger."

Beyond my enjoyment of the academic gossip the 'zine slings so freely, I'm also impressed by how easily Sign and Sight transforms discussion of high-brow matters like "negative theology" into digestible factoids that make a reader feel connected to the ongoing culture dialogue of the times.

Thursday, December 25, 2008

Sir Harold Pinter makes his holiday exit

Sad news comes of the death of Sir Harold Pinter, after his long battle with cancer.  Pinter's lesser plays more than occasionally tried to barter either shock or in-your-face banality for actual dramatic insight, and his reactive anti-Americanism was one of his least attractive qualities.  But when his writing clicked, there was nothing in contemporary drama that was more effective.  I saw a Broadway production of "No Man's Land" some years ago (with Jason Robards and Christopher Plummer in the two lead roles) that remains one of the genuinely mesmerizing pieces of theater I've ever seen.  

One can also have nothing but admiration for the stoically noble way he bore his extended illness. Six years ago he published a poem in the Guardian that remains a thrilling example of how a man can comtemplate with grim, black humor the hand tightening on his own throat:  

Cancer Cells

"Cancer cells are those which have forgotten how 
to die" - nurse, Royal Marsden hospital

They have forgotten how to die
And so extend their killing life.

I and my tumour dearly fight.
Let's hope a double death is out.

I need to see my tumour dead
A tumour which forgets to die
But plans to murder me instead.

But I remember how to die
Though all my witnesses are dead.
But I remember what they said
Of tumours which would render them
As blind and dumb as they had been
Before the birth of that disease
Which brought the tumour into play.

The black cells will dry up and die
Or sing with joy and have their way.
They breed so quietly night and day,
You never know, they never say.

Friday, November 14, 2008

In Penrose's The Emperor's New Mind there's an elegant discussion of what he calls the "reality the reals" - meaning: of the fact that reality seems to be quantifiable by uncountably many real numbers.   Penrose notes, of course, that in addition to not being subject to any well-ordered enumeration the reals can NOT, in total, be systematically generated by an infinitely repeating algorithm, thanks to the Turing "Halting Problem".  Nevertheless, despite the fact there is something conceptually elusive about them - at least as a class - the reals collectively (including such famous irrational reals as Pi and the Natural Logarithm) appear to be part of the make up of reality at the most fundamental level. 

Penrose goes on to observe that we can posit a second class of numbers - the imaginary and complex numbers - that seems even more abstract and intangible than our irrational, uncountable, infinitely repeating reals.  And yet, as with the reals, complex numbers have incredible predictive powers when describing the elemental behavior of reality - especially (as is well-known) on a quantum scale.

Fair enough, but what I'm puzzling over is this: if we can "imagine" a number that is the square root of a negative number - and if furthermore we can build various complex numbers with these imaginary numbers that accurately describe the behavior of manifold entities in the "natural world" - why can't we do the same thing with fractions in which the divisor is 0?  In other words, why can't I hypothesize a quantity - call it "n/0" - which has a similar imaginary component to any complex number of the form "a + bi"? 

I'm sure there's a good "number theoretic" answer to this question (the mighty Wikipedia speaks of division by zero as leading to "algebraic absurdities") and I conjecture that one corellary to the "no division by zero" rule is that one will *never* encounter natural phenomena that could through some mathematical slight-of-hand be represented by fractions in which the divisor is 0. 

But I still find it odd, and even irritating.  Of course, I am frequently odd and irritating myself.