Friday, November 14, 2008

In Penrose's The Emperor's New Mind there's an elegant discussion of what he calls the "reality the reals" - meaning: of the fact that reality seems to be quantifiable by uncountably many real numbers.   Penrose notes, of course, that in addition to not being subject to any well-ordered enumeration the reals can NOT, in total, be systematically generated by an infinitely repeating algorithm, thanks to the Turing "Halting Problem".  Nevertheless, despite the fact there is something conceptually elusive about them - at least as a class - the reals collectively (including such famous irrational reals as Pi and the Natural Logarithm) appear to be part of the make up of reality at the most fundamental level. 

Penrose goes on to observe that we can posit a second class of numbers - the imaginary and complex numbers - that seems even more abstract and intangible than our irrational, uncountable, infinitely repeating reals.  And yet, as with the reals, complex numbers have incredible predictive powers when describing the elemental behavior of reality - especially (as is well-known) on a quantum scale.

Fair enough, but what I'm puzzling over is this: if we can "imagine" a number that is the square root of a negative number - and if furthermore we can build various complex numbers with these imaginary numbers that accurately describe the behavior of manifold entities in the "natural world" - why can't we do the same thing with fractions in which the divisor is 0?  In other words, why can't I hypothesize a quantity - call it "n/0" - which has a similar imaginary component to any complex number of the form "a + bi"? 

I'm sure there's a good "number theoretic" answer to this question (the mighty Wikipedia speaks of division by zero as leading to "algebraic absurdities") and I conjecture that one corellary to the "no division by zero" rule is that one will *never* encounter natural phenomena that could through some mathematical slight-of-hand be represented by fractions in which the divisor is 0. 

But I still find it odd, and even irritating.  Of course, I am frequently odd and irritating myself.

No comments: