Sunday, January 25, 2009

Fincher's Digital Button

I saw "The Curious Caste of Benjamin Button" on Friday,  and now am reading F. Scott Fitzgerald's short-story of the same name; reading it more out of curiousity than anything else, since the connection between the movie and the fiction is tenuous.  As the Times'  A.O Scott noted in his review of the Fincher film, a more profound and obvious  influence on the movie is the preceeding work of directors like Steven Spielberg, Peter Jackson, and Robert Zemeckis - more specifically, the films where they create characters - or even entire worlds - out of computer-generated digital imagery.  I'm fine with the trend toward digital effects in the cinema - it's after one more technical advance at the disposal of our imaginitive resources - but it's wrong to think that the "better" digital technology becomes the more realistic it necessarily is.  While not thinking that Fincher's "Button" is a complete failure, I nonetheless found that there was something false and unbelieveable in Bratt Pitt's aging-in-reverse;  it seems to me that the film's lack of believability is directly related to its reliance on digital trickery.

No comments: